Persistent Urban Poverty: An Evaluation of Cultural Claims and Structural Explanatory Alternatives
Keywords:
culture of poverty, urban poverty, marginalized communities, structural, inequality, adaptation, public policyAbstract
The concept of a “culture of poverty” has often been used to explain persistent deprivation in marginalized urban communities. This literature review critically evaluates the concept and contrasts it with structural explanations. It finds the culture of poverty thesis fundamentally flawed. The argument relies on sweeping generalizations, essentializes diverse communities, and reverses causality by portraying rational adaptations to harsh constraints as independent cultural causes. By emphasizing values and attitudes, it risks blaming disadvantaged groups while obscuring deeper determinants. In contrast, structural perspectives offer a more convincing framework. Urban poverty is primarily produced and sustained by material conditions and unequal power relations. These include precarious labor markets, unequal access to housing and education, weak social protection systems, and political marginalization. Practices observed within poor communities are better understood as adaptive responses to structural constraints rather than as a self-perpetuating cultural syndrome. A credible analysis of urban poverty therefore requires transforming the economic, spatial, and political structures that restrict opportunities and life chances for marginalized populations.
References
Aisyah, N. & F. Issalillah. 2022. Social Stigma toward Mental Illness: Manifestations in Society and Barriers to Recovery, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(1), 307-332.
Al-Hakim, Y. R., & Irfan, M. 2024. Conflict Management and Harmony in Work Teams: Management Strategies, Causal Factors, and Impacts on Team Effectiveness. Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 4(1), 361-390.
Amri, M. W., & Khayru, R. K. 2022. Keeping Tradition in the Midst of Modernity: The Social Life of Indigenous Communities in Urban Areas. Journal of Social Science Studies, 2(1), 135-138.
Arifin, S., & Darmawan, D. 2022. Adaptive Approach in Crisis Management for Economic Uncertainty in Organization. Journal of Social Science Studies, 2(1), 271-276.
Bowen, G. A. 2009. Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research Method. Qualitative Research Journal, 9(2), 27–40.
Carter, P. L. 2005. Keepin' it Real: School Success Beyond Black and White. Oxford University Press, New York.
Chen, M. A. 2012. The Informal Economy: Definitions, Theories and Policies (WIEGO Working Paper No. 1). Women in Informal Employment: Globalizing and Organizing (WIEGO), 1-22.
Dahar, D., Arifin, S., Nuraini, R., & Mardikaningsih, R. 2022. Urban Forest: The role of improving the quality of the urban environment. Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society, 1(1), 25-29.
Darmawan, D. et al. 2021. Psychological Perspective in Society 5.0, Zahir Publishing, Jogjakarta.
Denzin, N. K., & Y. S. Lincoln. (Eds.). 2011. The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research (4th ed.). SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks.
Fauzi, A. 2021. Spatial Patterns of Poverty and Social Segregation in Metropolitan Areas, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(1), 147-160.
Fauzi, A. 2022. Gentrification in Urban Renewal and the Marginalization of Low Income Communities, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(1), 235-260.
Gani, A. 2022. The Colonialism-Vulnerability Nexus: A Political Ecology Study of Structural Inequality in Climate Change, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(1), 85-108.
Gautama, E. C., & Mardikaningsih, R. 2022. Driving Sustainable Behavior Change Through Education and Public Awareness. Journal of Social Science Studies, 2(1), 259-264.
Gautama, E. C., Mardikaningsih, R., Wisnujati, N. S., & Cruz, C. da. 2021. The Relationship between Employee Welfare and Public Organization Performance in Community Services. Journal of Social Science Studies, 1(2), 197-202.
Halizah, S. N., & Mardikaningsih, R. 2022. Accommodating Social Change in Sustainability Policy: Solutions for a Just and Relevant Society. Journal of Social Science Studies, 2(2), 299-304.
Hariani, M., & Al Hakim, Y. R. 2022. Analysis of Community Behavior Against the Use of Bio-Degradable Shopping Bags as a Substitute for Single-Use Plastic Bags. International Journal of Service Science, Management, Engineering, and Technology, 2(1), 1-4.
Hariani, M., & Halizah, S. N. 2024. Multicultural Perspective in Conflict Management Policy: A Literature Study on Challenges and Opportunities In Indonesia. Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 4(1), 337-360.
Irfan, M. & Y. R. Al Hakim. 2022. Changing Patterns of Human Relations in Contemporary Urban Society, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(1), 333-356.
Kalleberg, A. L. 2011. Good Jobs, Bad Jobs: The Rise of Polarized and Precarious Employment Systems in the United States, 1970s-2000s. Russell Sage Foundation, New York.
Khayru, R. K., Rojak, J. A., & Fajar, A. S. M. 2024. The Role of Media in the Global Era in Shaping Public Opinion on Conflict and the Implications for Democracy. Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 4(1), 417-438.
Lareau, A. 2011. Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life (2nd Ed.). University of California Press, Berkeley.
Mahmudah, S. 2021. Food Vulnerability of Poor Households in Densely Populated Urban Areas, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(2), 125-140.
Mahmudah, S. 2022. Economic Informality and Urban Worker Precarity in City Governance, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(2), 231-258.
Mardikaningsih, R. 2021. Urbanization and Social Inequality: Challenges in Building Social Cohesion in a City-Based Environment. Journal of Social Science Studies, 1(1), 135-140.
Mardikaningsih, R., & Hariani, M. 2021. Realizing Sustainability in Public Policy: Building a Balance between Economy, Social, and Environment. Journal of Social Science Studies, 1(1), 191-196.
Nuraini, R., Darmawan, D., Mardikaningsih, R., Hariani, M., & Halizah, S. N. 2022. Keberlanjutan kelestarian lingkungan: Peran kunci lokus kendali internal dan wawasan lingkungan dalam mendorong perilaku pro-lingkungan. TIN: Terapan Informatika Nusantara, 3(3), 116-122.
Nuraini, R., Handayani, S., Wisnujati, N. S., Darmawan, D., & Kurniawan, Y. 2021. Environmental Management and Law Enforcement. Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(1), 65-76.
Rejeki, S. 2021. Social Network Formation Through Shared Interest Communities in Urban Areas, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(1), 227-250.
Rejeki, S. 2024. Family Institutional Change in Contemporary Society Norms Authority and Obligations. Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 4(1), 229-254.
Rizky, M. C., & Udjari, H. 2021. Reflections on Social Welfare Theory in the Juridical Foundation of Sustainable Public Policy. Journal of Social Science Studies, 1(1), 185-190.
Rojak, J. A. 2021. The Effectively Leading Manifestation of Public Service-Oriented Governance. Journal of Social Science Studies, 1(2), 89-96.
Rojak, J. A., & Darmawan, D. 2012. Dinamika Keberagaman Gender dan Etnis dalam Organisasi Kontemporer. Jurnal Ekonomi dan Bisnis, 2(2), 45–58.
Rojak, J. A., Darmawan, D., Mardikaningsih, R., Ernawati, & Kemarauwana, M. 2012. Dinamika urbanisasi dan pola kemiskinan kota serta implikasi pencegahan. Jurnal Ekonomi dan Bisnis, 2(1), 53–65.
Rojak, J. A., R. K. Khayru, & D. Darmawan. 2021. Citizens’ Political Participation in Electoral Democracy and the Dynamics of Civil Society Movements, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(1), 161-176.
Saputra, R. & D. Darmawan. 2021. Between Individual Freedom and Collective Responsibility: Dynamics of Social Solidarity in the Age of Individualism, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(1), 251-274.
Small, M. L., Harding, D. J., & Lamont, M. 2010. Reconsidering Culture and Poverty. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 629(1), 6–27.
Standing, G. 2011. The Precariat: The New Dangerous Class. Bloomsbury Academic, London.
Warin, A. K. 2022. Social Relationship Between Urban Living Characteristics and Social Determinants of Population Health, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(2), 307-332.
Wilson, W. J. 2012. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy (2nd ed.). University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Wisnujati, N. S. & R. Mardikaningsih. 2021. Urban Sprawl, Daily Mobility, and Community Cohesion in Suburban Fringe Areas, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 1(2), 275-300.
Zahid, R. A., D. Darmawan, & R. K. Khayru. 2022. Mental Illness Stigma in Families and the Reach of Private Law Protection, Studi Ilmu Sosial Indonesia, 2(2), 207-230.
Zulkarnain, M. A. B., Khayru, R. K., Issalillah, F., & da Cruz, C. 2021. Citizen Engagement in Ecological Issue Management through Participatory Practices and Community-Based Social Supports. Journal of Social Science Studies, 1(1), 227-232.
